Il San Pietro di Positano

We were absolutely blown away by ISP. We usually stay at Treville, a few hundred metres away towards Positano, but as they were closing for the season we moved to ISP. Treville dropped us off in their boat, and we made our way up the lift to reception. As soon...

We were absolutely blown away by ISP. We usually stay at Treville, a few hundred metres away towards Positano, but as they were closing for the season we moved to ISP. Treville dropped us off in their boat, and we made our way up the lift to reception. As soon as stepped out of the lift we immediately decided to extend our stay for another night. The views are simply extraordinary, and a we were fortunate to be upgraded to a suite with a wall of glass overlooking Positano. Even the shower and tub had the same panoramic view. The food was exquisite, both at the informal beach restaurant and their Michelin restaurant, Zass. Yes, it is expensive, but the food and drink prices are very reasonable for a hotel of this quality. The mini bar was included, and they even threw in lunch on the beach on the final day when they were closing. Throughout the stay, there was huge generosity of spirit, with the most charming staff, led by the best GM we have ever experienced running the show front and centre. It is unfair to compare ISP with Treville - they are both world class hotels. Treville is akin to staying with friends in their incredible private villa, whereas ISP is the full 5 star hotel package with facilities and restaurants to match. But both excel at service, with nothing too much trouble. We can’t wait to visit again!

BEST Hotel we have EVER stayed at!!! The service was absolutely incredible, the staff go above and beyond and treat everyone with respect, young or old. They know you by name and make an effort to keep things personal. They have so many services that are available at the hotel...

BEST Hotel we have EVER stayed at!!! The service was absolutely incredible, the staff go above and beyond and treat everyone with respect, young or old. They know you by name and make an effort to keep things personal. They have so many services that are available at the hotel you could stay for days at a time and never run out of things to do. The complimentary breakfast is fantastic and the dinner at Zass was amazing. We are dreaming of the day we can come back here!

With so many luxury hotels in the world in spectacular settings, the affluent traveler has many choices. With that in mind, I do not think Il San Pietro in Positano is one of those that invites a revisit - maybe not even a visit for the first time. As others...

With so many luxury hotels in the world in spectacular settings, the affluent traveler has many choices. With that in mind, I do not think Il San Pietro in Positano is one of those that invites a revisit - maybe not even a visit for the first time. As others on the website have noted, Il San Pietro is no longer a small hotel of unique charm able to deliver discrete and personalized service at the highest level to the most exacting of international client. Instead, Il San Pietro is now a very beautiful but completely sterile “cookie cutter high end” hotel unable to deliver anything other than homogenized Relais & Chateaux service. Yes, it still occupies a privileged perch with its own “private beach” accessible by an elevator through the rocks. And yes, it is possible to reserve a large exquisitely furnished suite with enormous private “no one can see you” terrace – as we did – for $3500 a night (before tax) with sweeping and spectacular views of the Mediterranean. But if you do, be sure to pack your own soap and shampoo: The liquid hand and shower soap supplied by the hotel in a large plastic bottle is of inferior quality. Think Costco. In our case, the plastic containers did not even have workable pumpsIn the end, we used our own soap and shampoo from home. In a way, the worst part of our stay was our arrival. It took us two and one half hours on a low guard rail road through the mountains and then in bumper to bumper traffic, past hordes of Amalfi coast tourists, until we reached the hotel’s front door. When we sis finally arrive, there was no one to greet us. Instead, we proceeded on our own down an unmarked elevator to the hotel’s front desk, where we gave our name at the desk and a woman officiously asked for our American Express card. Not even a smile or question about our exhausting drive. After we handed over our card, she asked if this was our first time at the hotel. When I mentioned that we had actually spent our honeymoon at the hotel many years before – as I had written the hotel in details at the time I made our reservation - the woman’s completely bizarre reply was: “I checked your record. You did not write us.” A chilly reception for sure. Not what one expects in Southern Italy! The second worst part of our stay was the food. See separate review of the hotel’s Michelin starred restaurant, which should be avoided. The third was the absurdity of our departure. The bill -exorbitant though it was – was completely correct. However the problem was again the clumsy send-off. After we paid our bill, we were presented with great ceremony with a large box of beautifully perfumed Italian soap for which we had no room in our luggage. It certainly would have been a lot more appreciated to havebeen given the soap when we checked in! This being said, Il San Pietro is a beautiful hotel. The gardens that descend down thto the sea and our room itself was nothing short of spectcular. We just won't be going back!

I don’t even know where to start. This place is an absolute gem…the only place to stay in Positano. My husband and I were already planning our return while still on property. We stay at a lot of five-star hotels, and this was by far our favorite one in the...

I don’t even know where to start. This place is an absolute gem…the only place to stay in Positano. My husband and I were already planning our return while still on property. We stay at a lot of five-star hotels, and this was by far our favorite one in the world to visit so far. We were visiting for my birthday and our first wedding anniversary. It rained pretty much the whole time we were there so we had to cancel our private charter to Capri among other things. The concierge was super helpful, helping us move things around with the weather being what it was. We stayed in a Prestige Room I believe that was super spacious and had a massive covered terrace with 3-4 lounge chairs. Nice and private. Rooms are incredible, unique, and well decorated. Super comfortable and goodies delivered everyday. Restaurants are outstanding…Carlino was our personal favorite but Zass Michelin star restaurant is incredible, too. You have to have the lemon pasta at Carlino… I dream about it. Don’t skip the breakfast….the food is amazing and service outstanding. Having breakfast with that view might’ve been my favorite part of the whole trip. Love the branded bag and sandals at check-in. The daily amenities/activities are fun and exciting. Most notable is the pizza making class. So fun! The shuttle service is super responsive and quick only ~5 mins to town. The staff everywhere is amazing, so welcoming, and they really treat every guest as family. For my planning WAG’s out there, we looked at the other luxury properties in the area including Le Sirenuse. We went there for cocktails and while it was cool to see, I’m so glad we didn’t stay there. Part of the appeal of this property is that it sits outside of town so you don’t have the crowds and you get the quiet and the privacy which has gotten harder to find in Positano. The hotel ethos is also rooted in nature which we really loved and appreciated. One plus I have to call out… Dyson hairdryers in the rooms. Yas. I probably can say many more good things about this property but you just have to experience it for yourself. It is heaven. Everything about this property and their staff is exquisite. What a magical experience. We can’t wait to come back! Grazie mille a million times il San Pietro!!!

Il San Pietro’s hospitality made us feel welcomed and relaxed all the time. This gorgeous hotel made us feel we were part of a romantic movie with no end. Everyone and everything at this hotel is beyond perfect. All the personal, store front and back stage, is absolutely amazing and...

Il San Pietro’s hospitality made us feel welcomed and relaxed all the time. This gorgeous hotel made us feel we were part of a romantic movie with no end. Everyone and everything at this hotel is beyond perfect. All the personal, store front and back stage, is absolutely amazing and we can tell how much every one contributes to make their guests happy. Sipping Bellinis at the Il San Pietro terrace will be your happy memory, that will live rent free in your head for the rest of your life.

This is the most magical, enchanting hotel and place I have ever been. Nestled just 5 minutes outside of the main part of Positano (with an all hours shuttle that makes the city within reach at all times), it is a quiet oasis. I stayed here with my husband for...

This is the most magical, enchanting hotel and place I have ever been. Nestled just 5 minutes outside of the main part of Positano (with an all hours shuttle that makes the city within reach at all times), it is a quiet oasis. I stayed here with my husband for our anniversary and the service, food, and ambience was beyond excellent. I have had the opportunity to stay at many high end hotels for work and I can say this is the best hotel I have ever stayed at. Don't stay anywhere else!

My husband and I just returned from an amazing stay at San Pietro. The property is incredibly beautiful, and Andrea and his staff are so welcoming and attentive. We ate at both Zass and Carlino’s. We highly recommend both restaurants as the food and service were excellent. Our only regret...

My husband and I just returned from an amazing stay at San Pietro. The property is incredibly beautiful, and Andrea and his staff are so welcoming and attentive. We ate at both Zass and Carlino’s. We highly recommend both restaurants as the food and service were excellent. Our only regret was not having stayed longer!

HSP is a very special place. The entire staff is super friendly yet professional. Their attention to every detail is something you can't describe with words..it's an overall "vibe" that is present throughout the property. We stayed in several towns/cities throughout Italy to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary and HSP...

HSP is a very special place. The entire staff is super friendly yet professional. Their attention to every detail is something you can't describe with words..it's an overall "vibe" that is present throughout the property. We stayed in several towns/cities throughout Italy to celebrate our 30th wedding anniversary and HSP was by far our favorite place! The sea views, cliffs, gardens and the "beach" are beyond words. HSP is just a couple minutes outside of Positano and there is an on demand shuttle anytime you need them. I loved the location being away from the crazy hustle and bustle of Positano..yet we were only a 3 minute ride away. Perfection is hard to achieve and HSP comes very very close. I can't wait to go back!

Excellent in every way. Location, restaurants, pool, staff. Everything was A+. The suite overlooking the ocean was spectacular very friendly staff. Food was Michelin three star. Great place to call home in Italy for a couple for weeks. Really nice people

I don't have enough words to express our love for this hotel, our most memorable stay by far. Since arrival at Il San Pietro di Positano, the service has been nothing short of exceptional. The check-in experience was both professional and personable, taking the time to explain important details about...

I don't have enough words to express our love for this hotel, our most memorable stay by far. Since arrival at Il San Pietro di Positano, the service has been nothing short of exceptional. The check-in experience was both professional and personable, taking the time to explain important details about the hotel as well as letting us enjoy some peace and serenity having a welcome drink with insane views. Our room overlooking the sea is magnificent. The dinner at Zass was incredible, both in service and in flavors. Attention to detail at breakfast was beyond typical, making us feel at home & welcome as well as completely taken care of. We were able to experience the complimentary 2-hour boat tour of the Amalfi coast, which was a beautiful addition, as well as the cocktail masterclass where we learned so much about the origins of the Negroni and got to participate in the process of making our own cocktail. We've been to countless hotels around the world and the level of sophisticated service here surpasses every single one. All our needs were attended to beyond our expectations. We usually wait until check-out to write a review but this level of service needs cherishing and publicity for anyone debating where to stay in Positano or on the Amalfi coast. Thank you to all the staff and the general manager for putting so much thought and work into creating unforgettable experiences. Do not change anything, you are perfect!

I have wanted to visit this hotel for many years and, reading the reviews, I had extremely high expectations. It did not disappoint. This is a spectacularly good hotel with simply impeccable service. We stayed in an Elite room and it was so stunning I had to ask if we...

I have wanted to visit this hotel for many years and, reading the reviews, I had extremely high expectations. It did not disappoint. This is a spectacularly good hotel with simply impeccable service. We stayed in an Elite room and it was so stunning I had to ask if we had been upgraded (we hadn't). The room had three windows overlooking the sea, one of which was a double shower room. Every single amenity was contained within the room and the only one that wasn't initially (a kettle) was rectified immediately. We ate in both restaurants and both were excellent, albeit our favourite was Zass where the ebullient service and fantastic food made for an amazing evening. The cocktails were equally good, out on the terrace and in the beautiful lounge. We loved the exterior of the hotel - great beach area, tennis courts and indoor/outdoor gym, not to mention the beautiful grounds. We will definitely return to this hotel. It is such a special experience.

Il San Pietro is a very special place. From the moment you arrive on property you are made to feel welcomed and a part of the family. Everyone we encountered was professional, friendly, helpful and certainly went the extra mile without being asked. Everything about the team here was perfect....

Il San Pietro is a very special place. From the moment you arrive on property you are made to feel welcomed and a part of the family. Everyone we encountered was professional, friendly, helpful and certainly went the extra mile without being asked. Everything about the team here was perfect. During our stay, my wife’s birthday occurred and I had a few special requests for her special day. The hotel executed flawlessly and also went above and beyond to help celebrate her day. From the bellmen, the counter staff, concierge, beach staff, restaurant staff, housekeeping, and the management team, have never had better treatment from anywhere else in the world we have visited. Being our first time to Amalfi Coast, everyone took an interest in what we were interested in or what we liked before making suggestions and recommendations. This is unique in that most of the time you get a canned answer. Because of time constraints we couldn’t do everything suggested however what we were able to take advantage of from the suggestions was spot on. The rooms are well appointed, nicely done and the views are spectacular. Food was great and the beach area was awesome too. They welcome you with the warmest of hearts when you check-in, they also mention that it’s great to be there for the first of many visits to their hotel. That’s a tall promise to keep, I can tell you emphatically, they lived up to the promise. Il San Pietro is by far our most favorite place. Well Done, Il San Pietro team! Looking forward to coming back soon!

Heaven on earth. Fabulous location and hotel. Service beyond compare. My only mistake was not spending my whole trip there. In the top 3 of all places that I have stayed in the world. Would not change anything. Food, rooms, service all better than a 10 and worth every penny....

Heaven on earth. Fabulous location and hotel. Service beyond compare. My only mistake was not spending my whole trip there. In the top 3 of all places that I have stayed in the world. Would not change anything. Food, rooms, service all better than a 10 and worth every penny. Going back as soon as possible.

The most amazing location, amenities, service, food, drinks, ambiance...the highlight of our trip to the Amalfi Coast by far. The manager, the staff, the waiters, every single person went above and beyond to make our stay amazing. The hotel manager even gifted me with a bag of candies when my...

The most amazing location, amenities, service, food, drinks, ambiance...the highlight of our trip to the Amalfi Coast by far. The manager, the staff, the waiters, every single person went above and beyond to make our stay amazing. The hotel manager even gifted me with a bag of candies when my husband mentioned I loved the bedtime treat with the turndown service. We didn't even eat at Zass (we were too tired of tasting menus by this point in our trip) but heard amazing things and the casual restaurant, Bits and Bites on the terrace, and room service were phenomenal. If/when I return to the Amalfi Coast, I will stay no where else but Il San Pietro. Truly one of a kind experience. We went to Capri, Ravello, Amalfi - this was by far the best.